Red Flags Checklist
DOCX download
Red Flags Checklist
Free editable Word guide you can copy, fill in, and share with your band. Also readable on this page.
How to use this guide
Checklist of red flags when evaluating potential bandmates. Leave with a dated list of observed behaviors and one clear decision per candidate.
Fill in a row for every flagged behavior with its date, keep the log in a private leadership note, and pull it up again at each reassessment or new audition.
Red flags are not vibes—they are patterns that predict harm, chaos, or betrayal. Talent does not override safety or basic honesty.
Automatic stops
Certain discoveries end the evaluation on the spot: threats or harassment at a tryout, a lie about money or actual availability, or a flat refusal to share setlists and recordings like a professional. No amount of chops overrides these, because the bill for ignoring them arrives later and the whole lineup pays it.
A safety concern also changes how you meet: first auditions happen during the rehearsal studio's common hours with another member present, never alone in someone's basement. When your stomach drops reading a message thread, bring a second bandmate into the loop instead of handling it solo.
Soft flags that harden
Lateness with theatrical excuses, contempt for every past collaborator, and gear or files in permanent chaos start as soft warnings. They harden when the same behavior shows up twice during a four-week trial, so write down what happened and when instead of arguing from memory later.
A soft warning earns one direct conversation and a short observation window, not six months of silent hoping. Telling a candidate that arriving twenty minutes late twice is being watched gives them a fair chance and gives you clean grounds for whichever call comes next.
Repair versus exit
Some damage can repair when the person owns it without prompting, apologizes specifically, and stays changed for a stretch of weeks. Your hope cannot do the work for them; only their accountability can, and reliable members should not carry someone who refuses to acknowledge impact.
Booking one more jam to dodge a hard no is still a decision, and it taxes the four people who keep showing up in good faith. Set a two-rehearsal reassessment date, say plainly what must change, and let the calendar force the conversation everyone is avoiding.
Fill-in: Flags observed
Behavior / date: ________
Soft or hard?: ________
Discussed with candidate?: ________
Decision: ________
Putting it into practice
If you already see a hard flag, stop the hire process this week.
FAQ
Which red flags are automatic stops?
Safety threats, harassment, clear dishonesty about money or availability, and refusal of basic professional norms. Musical talent does not override safety.
What about soft flags?
Chronic lateness excuses, contempt for past collaborators, and chaos around gear or files. Soft flags become hard ones if the pattern continues in trial.
How do we document flags without gossip?
Write observable behaviors and dates in a private leadership note. Do not run a rumor campaign in the scene.
Can red flags be repaired?
Some can with accountability and time; others cannot. Repair requires the person’s ownership, not your hope.
